Sunday, October 25, 2026

Model Answer: Persuasive Writing

 

A technology company proposes installing AI-based employee-monitoring software that tracks keyboard activity, screen usage, and online working patterns. Management believes the system will improve accountability and identify inefficiencies. However, employees argue that continuous surveillance undermines trust, invades privacy, and fails to measure the quality of intellectual work.

Assume that you are the Human Resources Director. Prepare a persuasive memorandum of 250–300 words recommending an appropriate employee-performance evaluation policy. Balance managerial accountability with employee privacy, consider the limitations of digital monitoring, evaluate alternative performance measures, and present a convincing recommendation to the executive committee. (12 Marks)

Model Answer: Persuasive Writing on AI-Based Employee Monitoring

A. Planning and Developing the Persuasive Argument

1. Identify the issue

The technology company proposes using AI-based software to monitor keyboard activity, screen usage and online working patterns.

The central issue is how to ensure employee accountability without compromising privacy, trust or fair evaluation of intellectual work.

2. Identify the audience and purpose

  • Writer: Human Resources Director.
  • Audience: Executive Committee.
  • Purpose: Persuade the committee to adopt a fair, transparent and effective employee-performance evaluation policy.
  • Appropriate tone: Professional, balanced, respectful and solution-oriented.
  • Required format: A memorandum, rather than a letter.

3. Take a clear and defensible position

Recommend an outcome-based performance evaluation policy supported by regular managerial feedback and limited, transparent use of digital data.

The argument should not reject accountability. Instead, it should distinguish meaningful performance assessment from continuous surveillance.

4. Establish Ethos: credibility and trust

The Human Resources Director should demonstrate credibility through balanced judgement, recognition of organisational needs and fair treatment of employees.

The argument should:

  • Acknowledge management’s legitimate concern about accountability.
  • Recognise employees’ concerns about privacy and trust.
  • Avoid assuming that every use of monitoring is inappropriate.
  • Recommend clear safeguards and human review.
  • Avoid unsupported claims or invented research findings.

Suggested expression:

“As Human Resources Director, I support clear accountability, but our evaluation policy must assess meaningful contributions and provide fair procedures.”

5. Present Logos: evidence and logical reasoning

Use the details supplied in the case and explain the limitations of the proposed measures.

Proposed digital measure

Limitation to consider

Keyboard activity

Records typing activity, not necessarily the value or accuracy of work.

Screen usage

Does not, by itself, establish whether an employee is producing useful results.

Online working patterns

May not adequately represent time spent thinking, planning or discussing solutions.

The central reasoning is that activity data should not automatically be treated as evidence of work quality.

Suggested expression:

“An evaluation system should distinguish visible computer activity from valuable work rather than assume that the two are equivalent.”

6. Create Pathos: appropriate emotional appeal

Connect the recommendation with employees’ concerns about dignity, professional autonomy and fair recognition.

Suggested expression:

“Employees should feel accountable for their contribution, not anxious that every pause will be interpreted as poor performance.”

This appeal supports the argument without portraying management as uncaring or employees as unwilling to accept responsibility.

7. Anticipate the counter-argument

Present management’s strongest objection fairly:

“Without continuous monitoring, managers may struggle to identify disengagement, unequal workloads or inefficient working practices.”

This recognises the business concern behind the proposal.

8. Provide a reasoned rebuttal

Respond by proposing another route to accountability:

“Agreed targets, documented deliverables and regular reviews can provide a basis for accountability without making continuous surveillance the default.”

The rebuttal should acknowledge that alternative measures also require safeguards against unfairness.

9. Evaluate alternative performance measures

Alternative

Contribution to evaluation

Limitation or safeguard

Agreed objectives and deliverables

Focuses assessment on expected results

Targets must be realistic and appropriate to each role.

Quality assessment

Considers accuracy, usefulness and professional standards

Criteria should be defined clearly.

Regular managerial reviews

Provides opportunities for feedback and clarification

Reviews should be documented and consistent.

Project milestones

Makes progress visible before final completion

Milestones should accommodate justified changes.

Peer or client feedback

Adds perspectives on collaboration and service

Feedback should supplement, not determine, ratings.

Limited digital data

May provide supplementary context

Its purpose, access and retention should be clearly defined.

These are proposed policy options for the case, not guaranteed solutions.

10. Use AI as a debate partner

Students may use the following prompt:

“Act as a critical opponent. Challenge my recommendation for outcome-based employee evaluation instead of continuous AI monitoring. Identify weaknesses in my assumptions, proposed measures, privacy safeguards and approach to accountability. Distinguish reasoned objections from claims requiring external verification.”

For this model, the following points illustrate critical evaluation; they do not represent a separately obtained AI response:

  • Useful point: Outcome-based assessment must account for differences in task difficulty and employee responsibilities.
  • Possible limitation: An opposing argument may assume that digital activity data are automatically objective or accurate.
  • Claim requiring verification: Any assertion that monitoring software increases productivity by a particular percentage.
  • Additional counter-argument: Managerial assessment may introduce bias, so replacing digital monitoring alone does not guarantee fairness.

11. Refine the recommendation

Strengthen the policy by including:

  • Role-specific objectives and quality standards.
  • Regular, documented feedback.
  • Recognition of individual and team contributions.
  • Consistency checks across managers.
  • A clear process for employees to challenge ratings.
  • Transparent limits on any digital monitoring.
  • A pilot and review before wider implementation.

This refinement responds to objections rather than simply repeating the original position.

12. Distinguish persuasion from manipulation

The memorandum should persuade through balanced reasoning, not fear or distortion.

It should avoid:

  • Suggesting that all monitoring is necessarily abusive.
  • Implying that privacy removes employees’ responsibility to perform.
  • Presenting proposed benefits as proven results.
  • Inventing statistics, legal requirements or employee experiences.

The ethical position is to protect both organisational accountability and employees’ ability to understand and question how they are evaluated.

13. Conclude with a clear call to action

Ask the Executive Committee to approve a time-bound pilot of the proposed evaluation policy, with employee consultation, manager training and a review before wider adoption.

B. Final Model Memorandum

MEMORANDUM

To: Executive Committee
From: Human Resources Director
Date: 26 October 2026
Subject: Fair and Accountable Employee-Performance Evaluation

I recommend adopting an outcome-based performance evaluation policy rather than continuous AI surveillance. Accountability is essential, but employees should be assessed primarily on the quality, timeliness and value of their contributions, not keyboard activity or screen time.

The proposed software may reveal patterns requiring investigation. However, digital activity alone cannot establish the quality of intellectual work. Reading, planning and discussing solutions may involve little keyboard activity. Treating these indicators as performance scores risks confusing visible activity with meaningful achievement.

Management may argue that continuous monitoring offers consistent evidence and identifies disengagement. This concern deserves attention; nevertheless, agreed deliverables, project milestones and regular reviews provide a more relevant basis for assessing contribution. Managers should investigate performance concerns through discussion and documented evidence rather than automated assumptions.

I propose role-specific objectives covering output, quality, deadlines and collaboration. Monthly check-ins should address progress and obstacles, while quarterly reviews should combine managerial assessment with relevant peer or client feedback. Because these alternatives can also introduce bias, managers should use shared criteria, review ratings for consistency and provide an employee appeal process.

Employees deserve to understand how their work is judged without feeling that every pause is suspicious. Any supplementary digital monitoring should therefore have a clearly stated purpose, limited data collection, restricted access and defined retention periods. It should not independently determine disciplinary decisions.

I request approval for a 90-day pilot developed through employee consultation. Human Resources should train managers, publish the assessment criteria and review fairness, administrative costs and usefulness before recommending wider adoption. This policy would uphold managerial accountability while respecting employee privacy and professional judgement.